In Senate race, JD Vance’s call for higher taxes is only for certain corporations, corporate leaders

Early voting is under way in Ohio, and Republican-on-Republican attacks continue in the U.S. Senate race, with Mike Gibbons hitting J.D. Vance over taxes.

"J.D. Vance called for higher taxes," the narrator said in a Gibbons TV ad.

Vance is an author and venture capitalist. He has not called for tax increases broadly, only for certain corporate leaders and corporations.

The ad is based on a tweet that Vance posted in April 2021 in reply to CBS News reporter Ed O’Keefe.

Gibbons’ campaign did not reply to our request for information, but Vance’s tweet is cited in the ad.

O’Keefe tweeted about a "first-of-its-kind call between more than 100 top corporate leaders" on "how to respond to proposed changes in state voting laws." On the call were top leaders of airlines, media, law and investment, O’Keefe said.

Vance replied: "Raise their taxes and do whatever else is necessary to fight these goons. We can have an American Republic or a global oligarchy, and it’s time for choosing.

"At this very moment there are companies (big and small) paying good wages to American workers, investing in their communities, and making it easier for American families. Cut their taxes. No more subsidies to the anti-American business class."

Vance, whom former President Donald Trump endoresed, has also embraced tax increases for certain corporations. 

"By all means, let’s cut the taxes of the companies that invest in our country," Vance says on his campaign website: "But we’re going to raise taxes on companies that ship jobs overseas and use their money to fund anti-American radical movements. If these companies are going to wage war on America, it’s time America wages war on them."

Vance spokesperson Taylor Van Kirk told PolitiFact that Vance "has advocated for cutting taxes on companies who create jobs in America and wants to raise taxes on companies who are anti-American and who ship out jobs to China."

We didn’t find any instances of Vance calling for other tax increases.

The Ohio Senate seat is opening because Republican Rob Portman, who was elected in 2010, is not seeking re-election. 

Besides Gibbons, a businessman, and Vance, the Republican candidates include Ohio state Sen. Matt Dolan, former Ohio state treasurer Josh Mandel and former Ohio Republican Party chair Jane Timken. 

Featured Fact-check

John Kasich

stated on August 12, 2010

On whether to eliminate the state income tax.

As of April 19, the Real Clear Politics polling average put Mandel in the lead at 21%, followed by Gibbons at 19.3% and Vance at 14%. In a poll of likely GOP voters conducted April 13 to April 14 by Trafalgar Group, Mandel led with 28%, followed by Vance at 22.6% and Gibbons at 14.3%.

The leading Democratic candidates are U.S. Rep. Tim Ryan and consumer protection attorney Morgan Harper.

Overall, the race is rated by campaign watchers as "leans" Republican, "likely" Republican and "solid" Republican.

Gibbons said in an ad that Vance "called for higher taxes."

This is partly true. Vance has called for tax hikes on certain corporate leaders and corporations. But he has not called for tax increases broadly. 

We rate Gibbons’ statement Half True.

RELATED: Fact-checks in the 2022 Ohio Senate race

RELATED: The race for the Ohio U.S. Senate seat: A guide

RELATED: Fact-checking ads in the 2022 elections